How Scouts Evaluate QBs

Quarterback is one of the most scrutinized positions in football recruiting. College scouts evaluate QBs using a comprehensive set of criteria that goes far beyond just arm strength and completion percentage. Here's what they're really looking for:

Arm Talent and Accuracy

Arm Strength: Scouts want to see you make all the throws required at the college level. This includes:

- Deep ball accuracy (40+ yards)

- Velocity on intermediate routes

- Ability to fit throws into tight windows

Accuracy: Completion percentage matters, but scouts also evaluate:

- Ball placement (leading receivers, throwing to the correct shoulder)

- Consistency across different route types

- Accuracy under pressure

Decision Making

This is often the most critical factor. Scouts evaluate:

- Pre-snap recognition and adjustments

- Post-snap processing speed

- Risk management (knowing when to take chances vs. protect the ball)

- Ability to read coverages and progress through reads

Mobility and Athleticism

Modern college football requires QBs who can:

- Extend plays with their legs

- Pick up first downs when needed

- Avoid sacks and negative plays

- Operate effectively in RPO (Run-Pass Option) systems

Leadership and Intangibles

Scouts look for:

- Command of the huddle

- Poise under pressure

- Work ethic and film study habits

- Ability to elevate teammates

Film Presentation Tips

When creating your highlight reel:

1. Show progression: Include clips from different game situations (red zone, two-minute drill, third downs)

2. Include full plays: Don't just show completions—show your process

3. Demonstrate variety: Show different throws (deep, intermediate, short, on the run)

4. Highlight football IQ: Include clips showing pre-snap adjustments and post-snap reads

What Separates Elite QBs

The QBs who get Power 5 offers typically demonstrate:

- Consistent accuracy at all three levels

- Quick processing and decision-making

- Ability to make "wow" throws that others can't

- Leadership qualities that teammates respond to

- Continuous improvement year over year

Getting Professional Feedback

The best way to understand how scouts view your game is to get professional evaluations from verified college scouts. They can provide specific, actionable feedback on your strengths and areas for improvement, helping you develop the skills that college programs are looking for.

Ready to get professional QB evaluation? Submit your film to verified college scouts on Got1 and receive detailed feedback on your game.